top of page

Shin the Musician

Last update: July 3, 2026

The John Shinnick Web Site

The recording, lyrics, and back story to "My Brain Is Too Small", a song I wrote and recorded in 1990.

Inspiration?

 

Last year, an icon from my youth and into my thirties, re-emerged to play a series of concerts, one of which I had the pleasure of attending. It was Peter Asher. You may not know the name Peter Asher, but if you were listening to music during the so-called “British Invasion” you may well remember a duet which went by the name Peter and Gordon. Yes, that Peter Asher. His sister Jane was engaged to Paul McCartney though they almost married. He went on to discover James Taylor and has produced albums by Taylor, Linda Ronstadt, Carole King, Bonnie Raitt, Diana Ross, J. D. Souther, Cher, Neil Diamond, Randy Newman, and Barbara Streisand. Among others. And he’s in the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame.

 

I loved that concert, so when I heard he was returning this year and that a group of friends were going to attend, I added my name to the list. The venue was the same, the intimate (I’m guessing about 200 people) Village Theater in Danville, California. The day of the concert I received an email from the concert promoters that began with a reference to Peter having recently broken his leg. My immediate thought was that there were complications and the concert had been cancelled. But no, it only prefaced that there would be a couple of small adjustments. Not too surprising having just turned 82.

 

The concert, like the previous year’s version was billed as both music and story-telling. And Asher certainly has a wealth of great stories that make many of the events of the past come to life, like how Peter and Gordon’s first hit “A World Without Love”, (a song which IMDB describes as having been written for them by Lennon and McCartney) was actually a half-written song McCartney had written for the Beatles but was rejected by Lennon who utterly hated it. So Paul finished it without Lennon’s help and offered it to Asher for his act. And the rest is history.

 

Or how Carole King had pitched her song “You’ve Got a Friend” to James Taylor and Asher who not only agreed on the song’s value, but also thought to add her to Taylor’s show as his pianist, then later as his opening act. Then to record as a solo artist. And the rest is history. Or how much he utterly hated the song “Lady Godiva” (though not as much as “Knight in Rusty Armor”) but Gordon won that argument and, well, you know…

 

Musically, Asher was backed by a most excellent keyboard player and a most excellent mandolin / fiddle player. It was the keyboard player who immediately noticed that Asher’s guitar was way out of tune. I thought he had his capo on the wrong fret. Asher gave the guitar to he keyboardist who took it offstage for tuning, but other than that, things ran smoothly. Except that about halfway in, Asher sat down because indeed his leg wasn’t as strong as it needed to be.

Asher was also getting over a cold. How much this affected his voice I don’t really know. He was not as strong a singer as last year, easily third best of the three on stage. You may recall that I saw Noel (Paul) Stookey recently, and at 89, his voice remains a booming baritone with wonderful resonance, and his guitar playing was remarkable. But in neither case, did really go for the music. I went for the memories of who and what these two performers had been. That one of them still was, was a flat-out inspirational bonus. And the Asher performance was still worth seeing for the memories it evoked. One of my friends I went to the concert with remarked that this would likely be his last tour. All the better reason to see him.

 

And what of John Shinnick’s legacy? I managed to get sidetracked in my efforts to finish up some of my own songs and get them recorded. Little things are deterring me, but I need to get back on the bicycle so to speak. My voice especially is on its decline. My guitar skills were never going to get me into the rock and roll hall of fame. So, while I still can, I need to put pedal to the metal to finish up some of my tunes in the making while (if?) I still can!

The video, lyrics, and back story of the song I wrote and performed for my retirement party in 2006.

Peter Asher, then and now.

My 10 favorites of all time

bottom of page